GrowthLife GrowthLife Call us

Traffic dropped after the September spam update — how do I work out what got hit?

growth life

Google’s September 2026 spam update finished rolling out on 8 October. A lot of site owners lost rankings and are now guessing at the cause. This is the diagnosis in the order that actually narrows it down, and what recovery realistically looks like.

Quick answer if you’re skimming

  • The rollout finished 8 October 2026. If your drop started well before 25 September or well after 8 October, this probably isn’t your cause.
  • Using AI to write is not the violation. “Scaled content abuse” is, and that applies however the pages were made.
  • Check Manual Actions and Security Issues in Search Console first. Clean there means it’s algorithmic, and there is no reconsideration request to file.
  • Recovery runs in months, not days. One widely-cited case took five months.
  • The fix is almost always removing and consolidating pages, not publishing more.

Was it actually the spam update, or something else?

  • Google confirmed the September 2026 spam update finished rolling out on 8 October 2026.
  • Match your drop to those dates before accepting the story. Losses starting outside that window point elsewhere.
  • Open Search Console → Manual Actions and Security Issues before anything else. A manual action is a different problem with a different fix.
  • Rule out the boring causes: an expired SSL certificate, a noindex pushed to production, a robots.txt change, a migration, a GA4 tag that got removed.
  • Compare Search Console impressions against GA4 sessions. If impressions held steady and sessions fell, you have a tracking or click-through problem, not a ranking one.
What you’re seeing Likely cause Where to look

 

Impressions flat, clicks down CTR or SERP layout change Search Console, query-level CTR
Impressions and clicks both down from late September Algorithmic ranking loss Page-level export either side of 8 Oct
A warning in Search Console Manual action Manual Actions report
Sessions down, impressions steady Tracking or site breakage GA4 tag, server logs
One folder down, rest steady Section-level content problem Group URLs by pattern

What did this update actually target?

  • Content policies, not links. The August 2026 run of the same family explicitly did not target link spam.
  • Named patterns: scaled content abuse, thin affiliate pages, doorway pages, scraped content.
  • Analysts tracking the rollout reported drops concentrated on highly templated and programmatic pages.
  • Expired-domain resurrection, coupon wrapper pages and republished wire content were all reported as hit.
  • Drops showed up in AI Overviews and AI Mode too, not only in the standard results.

Does using AI to write mean I get penalised?

  • No. Google’s stated position is that using AI is not itself a violation.
  • The line is scaled content abuse, which applies “no matter how it’s created.”
  • On 1 October 2026 Google updated its generative-AI guidance. That was a documentation change to match what they had been saying at developer events, not a new penalty.
  • The guidance asks for manual fact-checking before publishing, and says that review extends to title elements, meta descriptions, structured data and image alt text.
  • Fake author profiles — invented names, AI-generated headshots, credentials nobody holds — are treated as deception. That part is a genuine risk and worth auditing.

How do I find which pages got hit?

  • Export 16 months of Search Console performance data today. The window rolls off and you cannot get those weeks back.
  • Compare the four weeks before 25 September against the four weeks after 8 October, page by page.
  • Sort by lost clicks in absolute terms, then separately by lost impressions. The two lists rarely match, and the difference tells you something.
  • Group the losses by URL pattern. Programmatic sections tend to fall together.
  • Check whether the drop is confined to one section or spread across the site.

Is this page-level or site-level?

  • Case studies from the August run found impact “across sections” on some sites, meaning site-level.
  • One documented site had over 1.5 million URLs indexed with roughly 85% sitting in a programmatic section, and lost rankings across the whole domain.
  • If your genuinely good pages fell alongside the thin ones, assume the domain is carrying it.
  • That changes the fix. Trimming one folder will not help if the ratio of thin pages to substantial ones is the actual problem.

What does recovery actually involve?

  • Pruning, consolidating and removing. Not publishing more.
  • Pick a side for every weak page: improve it properly, merge it into a better page, or remove it and serve a 410 or a redirect.
  • Fix the metadata as well. Templated titles and descriptions across thousands of URLs read as scaled content on their own.
  • There is no reconsideration request for an algorithmic hit. You change the site, then wait for recrawling and the next update.
  • Write down what you changed and when. Otherwise the next move is a guess built on a guess.

How long before it comes back?

  • Months. Everyone tracking these updates says the same thing.
  • One widely-cited recovery took five months.
  • Some sites recover partially. Some never do, usually the ones where the thin pages were the business model rather than a mistake.
  • Anyone promising recovery by a specific date is telling you something useful about themselves.

What should this cost in India?

  • Published agency rate cards put ongoing SEO somewhere between ₹10,000 and ₹2,00,000 a month depending on scope.
  • Typical bands from those cards: freelancer ₹3,000–₹25,000, small agency ₹15,000–₹60,000, mid-tier ₹40,000–₹1,50,000.
  • A one-time audit is the piece you actually need here, and it’s priced by page count: roughly ₹5,000–₹25,000 under 100 pages, ₹25,000–₹75,000 for 100–500 pages, ₹75,000 and up beyond that.
  • Add 18% GST.
  • These are rate cards agencies publish, not survey data. Use them as a sanity check on a quote you’ve been given, not as a market benchmark.

Where does an agency fit, if at all?

  • Most of the diagnosis above you can do yourself with Search Console and a spreadsheet. Do that part first regardless.
  • It’s worth paying for when the site is large enough that pruning needs judgement at scale, or when nobody internally will own deleting things.
  • Ask any agency to show you the page-level before-and-after export, not a traffic graph with an arrow on it.
  • A free first-pass audit is a low-commitment way to get a second opinion. GrowthLife runs one, and so do plenty of others.

What I’d actually do

  • Export your Search Console data today, before the 16-month window drops the pre-update weeks.
  • Spend the first hour ruling out manual actions and technical breakage, because those have much faster fixes than content pruning.
  • Take your twenty worst pages by lost clicks, decide improve / merge / delete on each one, then leave the site alone for a month.

Keep reading

More from the blog

Your next step

Want this fixed on your site?

Get a free AI roast of your website in about 60 seconds — or talk to a human who fixes it for a living.