GrowthLife GrowthLife Call us

Is SEO still worth paying for when AI is answering the question before anyone clicks?

growth life

Three threads went up in digital marketing inside about 36 hours last week arguing opposite sides of this, and Indian start-up’s asked the blunt version: why are founders still paying heavy money for SEO. Here is what the actual numbers say, what GEO and AEO really mean, and how to tell whether your own SEO spend is still earning its keep.

Quick answer if you’re skimming

  • Referral traffic from ChatGPT is still tiny next to Google organic. One widely-discussed figure last week put it under 1% of Google organic volume.
  • Google’s own documentation says optimising for generative AI search is still SEO. There is no separate discipline to buy.
  • “GEO” and “AEO” are mostly new labels on existing work: clean structure, clear answers, entity consistency, being cited elsewhere.
  • What has actually changed is the click rate on informational queries, not the value of ranking.
  • If your SEO invoice can’t be traced to pipeline, the problem is usually the reporting, not the channel.

So is SEO dead or not?

  • No, but the easy half of it is. Queries with a factual one-line answer increasingly get resolved on the results page.
  • Queries where someone is choosing, comparing or buying still produce clicks, because people don’t commit money off a summary.
  • The digital marketing thread that got the most traction last week argued ChatGPT referrals sit under 1% of Google organic and aren’t the metric to watch.
  • A post the next day claimed 4,647 visitors from ChatGPT to a brand new site. Treat single-site numbers as anecdote; that one was also posted twice, which is worth noticing.
  • Both can be true. A tiny share of a very large number is still a real number for one site in one niche.

What are GEO and AEO, honestly?

  • GEO is generative engine optimisation. AEO is answer engine optimisation. Both describe getting cited inside AI-generated answers.
  • Google’s documentation addressed this last week and its position is that optimising for generative AI search is still SEO.
  • Practically that means: answer the question in the first two lines, keep your structure clean, keep your entity details consistent everywhere, and get mentioned on sources the models already read.
  • There is a newer, concrete piece: publishing an llms.txt file, the same idea as robots.txt but aimed at AI crawlers. Adoption is not universal and it is not a ranking lever.
  • If an agency is quoting you a separate GEO retainer on top of SEO for the same deliverables, ask them to show you which line items are new.

Then why does the agency invoice feel like it stopped working?

  • Informational blog traffic is the part being eaten. If your reporting leads with sessions, your chart will look worse than your business is doing.
  • Lead volume dashboards hide quality problems. One Indian founder posted last week about generating 2,279 “leads”, of which 452 were other agencies, roughly one in five.
  • Rankings for terms nobody buys from have always been decorative. AI answers just made that obvious.
  • A lot of retainers quietly drifted into content volume because content volume is easy to invoice.

What should I actually be measuring instead?

  • Branded search volume over time. It is the cleanest proxy for whether anyone is hearing about you.
  • Non-brand organic entries to pages that sit near money: pricing, comparison, category, product.
  • Assisted conversions, not last click. Organic usually shows up in the middle of an Indian B2B cycle, not at the end.
  • Share of qualified pipeline that mentions finding you via search, captured as one field on the enquiry form.
  • Citations in AI answers for your own category terms. Check it manually once a month; you don’t need a tool yet.

What is a fair price for SEO in India?

  • I’m not going to give you a benchmark figure. There is no reliable public dataset for Indian SEO retainers, and most numbers you’ll see quoted are made up.
  • Judge the quote instead of the number. Ask what the first 30 days produce, who does the work, and what happens if nothing moves by month four.
  • Be wary of any proposal priced per blog post. It aligns the agency with volume, not outcomes.
  • Be equally wary of a quote with no price at all until you’ve had three calls.
  • Compare against the honest alternative: what the same money buys in paid search, and whether you’d rather rent the traffic than own it.
Option In-house hire Freelancer Agency

 

Best when SEO is core to the business model One specific gap: tech audit, content, links You need several skills but not full-time
Real risk One person’s blind spots become yours Capacity vanishes without warning Juniors doing the work, seniors on the call
Ramp time Slowest Fastest Middle
Ask before signing Who mentors them? Who covers if you’re unavailable? Name the people on my account

When should I just stop doing SEO?

  • If your entire category has search volume in the low hundreds a month, your money is better spent on outbound or marketplaces.
  • If you sell on Amazon or Flipkart and most buying happens there, fix listings first. That is a different optimisation job.
  • If you need revenue inside 90 days, SEO is the wrong instrument. Say so out loud and buy paid search instead.
  • If you have no one who can approve content quickly, SEO will stall regardless of who you hire.

What does good look like right now?

  • Fewer pages, each one actually answering a question a buyer has.
  • Comparison and pricing pages that a model can quote without paraphrasing you badly.
  • Consistent business details across your site, Google Business Profile and any directory you’re in.
  • A technical base that loads fast on a mid-range Android on 4G, because that is your real user in India.
  • Being referenced somewhere other than your own site. This is the part most retainers skip and it’s the part that now matters most.

What I’d actually do

  • Pull the last six months of organic entries, split them into informational and commercial, and look at the two lines separately before concluding anything.
  • Rewrite your top five commercial pages so the answer is in the first two lines, then check in a month whether you’re being cited in AI answers for those terms.
  • If you’re paying a retainer, ask for one report that maps spend to pipeline. If nobody can produce it in a week, that tells you more than any ranking chart.

Keep reading

More from the blog

Your next step

Want this fixed on your site?

Get a free AI roast of your website in about 60 seconds — or talk to a human who fixes it for a living.